Metallothionein Protection against Alcoholic Liver Injury through Inhibition of Oxidative Stress
*Departments of Medicine, Pharmacology, and Toxicology, University of Louisville School of Medicine, Louisville, Kentucky 40202; and †Jewish Hospital Heart and Lung Institute, Louisville, Kentucky 40202
Summary:
Serum alanine aminotransferase (ALT) activity was colorimetrically measured using a Diagnostic Kit from Sigma Chemical. It was found that ALT levels increased after ethanol consumption in wild type mice, but remained constant for MT-TG mice.
To determine hisopathological effects, the liver tissues were cut into 3mm thick slices, fixed with 10% neutral formalin, stained with hematoxylin and eosin then photographed. It was seen that the primary effect of ethanol in wild type mice was microvesicular steatosis. Some hepatocyte necrosis was also observed by cell enlargement and nuclear dissolution. In MT-TG mice, ethanol only caused minor microvesicular steatosis.
To observe ethanol induced ultrastructural changes, the livers were fixed by vascular perfusion, and observed using a transmission electron microscope. It was observed that wild type mice who received ethanol had glycogen and fat accumulation, organelle abnormality, focal cytoplasmic degeneration, mitochondrial abnormalities and endoplasmic reticulum degeneration. In MT-TG mice, there was much less glycogen and fat accumulation and no change to the organelles.
A and B are normal liver samples from wild type and MT-TG mice, respectively. (C and E) and (D and F) are livers from wild type and MT-TG mice that received ethanol. M, mitochondria; RER, rough endoplasmic reticulum; L, lipid droplets; G, glycogen; FCD, focal cytoplasmic degeneration
Oxidized protein levels were based on carbonyl concentrations. Liver tissues homogenized, then 1.0 ml of homogenate was combines with w ml of 10 mM DNPH and 2 N HCL. The mixture was incubate for 1 hour at room temp, then the protein was precipitated out. The protein was dissolved again and insoluble debris was removed by centrifuge. The DNPH derrivated were measured at 360 nm. The concentration of carbonyl groups was calculated by using an absorbance coefficient 22 mM−1 cm−1. It was determined that protein carbonyl levels increased 2.7x in wild type mouse liver and that there was no significant increase in MT-TG mice.
Comments on the Experiment:
Over all, I believe these researchers had an excellent experiment. Rather than focusing on one particular outcome, they did multiple types of test to examine MT’s effect at protecting against alcohol. However one issue I had with this experiment was when they visualized liver samples. They provide example photos but do not discuss in detail how they compared images between wild type and MT-TG mice. Their lack of description in their protocol makes me assume they just eyed it, without taking significant measurements. Although their examples show a clear difference, I would be more comfortable if they did some analysis with ImageJ.
URL: http://ebm.rsmjournals.com/cgi/reprint/227/3/214.pdf
2 comments:
This paper is a very interesting. One thing I feel would be interesting with this paper is a long term study on the effects of alcohol with respect to liver tissue health. It seems like 3 doses of ethanol is a rather short model, even for binge drinking. I’m actually quite surprised that the responses are as pronounced as they are, given the short sampling time. What would happen if they extended the study to multiple dosages and/or longer time scales?
Another thing I feel is missing is a quantitative measure of viability. Their histological sections do not seem particularly suited to answering this question, as necrosis is only indicated by arrows, which may or may not be representative. It would be good to see a viability assay on the liver cells.
Did they discuss the specific effects MT has on cells, especially since they ran an experiment measuring the protein carbonyl increase? In this sense, I feel they could run more biochemical assays (eg. assaying for AST in addition to ALT) to verify their results instead of depending on qualitative discussion of their histological sections which you and Charles have pointed out was poorly analyzed. As for the 4 hour duration, was this derived from previous literature studies where 4 hours is the metabolic optimum for mice?
Post a Comment